So how do you set boundaries without being the bad guy? That’s a question I hear from new managers, seasoned executives, and pretty much everyone in between. Underneath it is a quieter worry: if I hold the line, will my team still like me? My answer comes down to four words that changed how I think about leadership. Clear is kind.
That phrase belongs to Brené Brown, and I’ll share where it comes from in a minute. What I want to talk about here is the trade so many of us make without noticing. We pick being liked over being clear, and we tell ourselves it’s the kind thing to do. Below I’ll unpack what I said in this Short, why the “I need to be liked” mindset quietly costs you the trust you’re trying to protect, and how to be clear and warm at the same time.
What I Shared in This Video
In the video I start with something that surprises people. At some point, being nice is a liability. At some point, being flexible is a liability. In a leadership role, what you have to be is consistent. You have to be mindful of the culture, and you need a few nonnegotiables that don’t move depending on who is asking or how the day is going.
I also make a claim that sounds backward until you’ve lived it. When you create boundaries and you’re super consistent about them, you’re more likable, not less. People can rely on you. They aren’t wondering whether you got a good night’s sleep or whether you’re about to change your mind. And at the end of the video, I let Brené Brown have the last word, because she says it best.
Clear Is Kind: Where the Phrase Comes From
“Clear is kind. Unclear is unkind.” Brené Brown made the line famous in her book Dare to Lead, and in an excerpt on her website she is open about where she first heard it: in a twelve step meeting about two decades before the book. She didn’t think much about it again until her research team saw a pattern in their interviews with leaders.
In her words, the data showed that “most of us avoid clarity because we tell ourselves that we’re being kind, when what we’re actually doing is being unkind and unfair.” She gives a few examples that land hard. Feeding people half truths to make them feel better is unkind. Not getting clear about your expectations because it feels too hard, and then blaming someone for not delivering, is unkind. Talking about people instead of to them is unkind.
Most leaders who stay vague aren’t trying to be difficult. They’re trying to be nice. Brené’s point, and mine, is that nice and kind are not the same thing.
The “I Need to Be Liked” Business
Here’s how I put it in the video. If you’re in the “I need to be liked” business, you’re going to compromise some of your core values. You’re going to compromise some of the things your team actually needs from you. And it’s going to make you seem more subjective as a leader.
That last part matters. When decisions depend on who you like, who pushed back the hardest, or who you’d rather not disappoint, your team stops seeing a standard. They see a personality they have to manage. The people doing good work start wondering why the rules seem to bend for someone else. Nobody wants to follow a leader who can’t be consistent.
Wanting to be liked is human. The trouble starts when that want begins making your decisions for you. That’s why I think untangling who you are from how your work is received is such important work for leaders.
Why Being Nice Can Become a Liability
Nice is about keeping the moment comfortable. Kind is about what actually helps the other person. Most of the time they line up. When they don’t, nice usually wins, because nice protects us. Brené makes this exact point: the half truths we tell to make someone feel better are almost always about making ourselves more comfortable.
In her research, more than half of the leaders talked about a cultural norm of being “nice and polite” that gets used as an excuse to avoid saying the real thing. I see it in the teams I work with: a request softened until it no longer sounds like a request, or a missed commitment that slides once, then again.
Years ago I wrote about the trap of going too easy on people in their first 90 days. Same idea. Holding back clarity feels generous in the moment, and it leaves people guessing about what matters.
What Unclear Leadership Looks Like Day to Day
Unclear leadership rarely looks dramatic. It looks like a lot of small, well meaning choices that add up to confusion. A few I see often:
- Hinting at what you want instead of asking for it.
- Saying “maybe” or “we’ll see” when you already know the answer. I’ve written about why a fast, honest no often serves everyone better.
- Making exceptions for the people you like most or the people who complain the loudest.
- Holding a standard firmly on Monday and loosely on Friday.
- Agreeing in the meeting, then reversing the decision in a hallway conversation.
- Venting about someone’s performance to a peer instead of telling the person.
None of these come from bad intentions. All of them leave your team guessing.
Consistency Makes You More Likable, Not Less
Here’s the piece leaders tend to get backward. Consistency is not the opposite of being liked. It’s one of the main reasons people end up liking and respecting their leader.
Think about the best boss you ever had. I’d bet you knew where you stood with them. You didn’t have to read their mood before bringing them a problem. That steadiness is a gift. It lets people spend their energy on the work instead of on managing you.
When a leader’s standards shift with their mood, everyone pays for it. If you notice your decisions swing with your stress level, my thoughts on pausing before you decide when emotions are running the show may help.
What Research Says About Unpredictable Bosses
There’s a study I share with leaders because it’s so counterintuitive. Researchers from Michigan State University, led by Fadel Matta and published in the Academy of Management Journal, compared people whose supervisors were consistently fair, consistently unfair, and fair one moment and unfair the next. As ScienceDaily’s summary of the study explains, about 160 college students did a task while their heart rates were monitored, and the group that got erratic treatment showed more stress than the group treated unfairly the whole time.
The team found the same pattern in a field study of workers and supervisors from 95 employers, surveyed daily over three weeks. Employees with unpredictable bosses reported more stress, lower job satisfaction, and more emotional exhaustion than employees whose boss was consistently unfair. The best outcomes still came from supervisors who were consistently fair, but the takeaway is striking: people seem to value predictability as much as fairness itself.
In a write up from the University of Georgia’s Terry College of Business, Matta put it simply: “It boils down to uncertainty in how you’re going to be treated.” He also advises leaders not to try to make up for an unfair call by overcorrecting later, and to tell people about constraints before they hit, like a raise that isn’t possible this year. That is clear is kind in action.
Flexible on the Plan, Firm on the Standards
If you’ve read my take on balancing a solid plan with the willingness to adjust it, you might be wondering how that fits with “flexibility is a liability.” Here’s the distinction I make. Plans should change when new information shows up. Standards for how we treat each other and what we owe one another should not change because someone is disappointed or because you’d rather avoid an awkward moment.
Be flexible about the route. Be steady about the values.
Decide Your Nonnegotiables Together
One line from the video is my favorite description of a leader’s job: “My job is to enforce the rules of engagement that we have decided on as a team.” Notice the words “as a team.” Clear boundaries work best when people helped shape them.
Here’s a simple way to do that. Set aside part of one team meeting and ask, “What are the three to five things we all agree we will always do, no matter how busy it gets?” Keep them concrete. “We respond to client emails within one business day.” “We bring problems to the person involved before anyone else.” “We start meetings on time.” Write them down in plain language and agree on what happens when one gets missed.
This is different from the one on one expectations you set when you delegate a project. I covered those in my guide to letting go of control while still keeping work on track, including the idea of treating everybody equally but not the same. Team nonnegotiables are the shared floor. Individual support can still look different for each person, which is something I explored in how different temperaments shape the way people work together.
Clear Boundaries Create Psychological Safety
In the video I say that being firm about boundaries is what makes you the person people look to when things get stressful. They know they can count on you. That certainty creates psychological safety for the team.
People sometimes assume psychological safety means everything is soft and flexible. It’s closer to the opposite. People take risks, speak up, and admit mistakes when they know the ground rules won’t suddenly change under them. I dug into this in what separates teams that thrive under pressure, and it’s also why keeping your word in small daily moments matters so much. Predictable leaders are safe leaders.
How to Be Clear Without Being Harsh
Clear doesn’t mean cold. You can say the true thing in a warm voice. What makes something clear is that the other person walks away knowing exactly what you meant. A few examples of what that sounds like:
- “I can’t approve that this quarter. Here’s why, and here’s when I can look at it again.”
- “That isn’t how we agreed to treat each other on this team. I need it to stop.”
- “I need the draft by Thursday at noon. If that’s a problem, tell me today.”
- “I don’t know yet. I’ll have an answer for you by Friday.”
Short sentences help, and so does saying the main point first. If the clear thing you need to say is a bigger one, like a performance issue someone keeps repeating, I walk through the full process in my piece on the conversations leaders keep putting off.
Signs You’re Choosing Liked Over Clear
Here are some honest questions to ask yourself. If you say yes to more than a couple, it may be time for a reset.
- Do your best people seem frustrated by rules that only apply to them?
- Do team members ask a coworker what you “really meant” after you talk?
- Have you reversed a decision mainly because someone was unhappy with it?
- Would your team describe your standards as depending on the day?
When You’ve Been Unclear for a While
If this hits close to home, you’re in good company. Most of us have let something drift. The fix starts with owning it. Something like, “I haven’t been consistent about how we handle deadlines, and that’s on me. Here’s what I’m committing to from now on.” If people were hurt along the way, my thoughts on repairing trust once it’s been damaged apply here too.
Then reset the standard in front of the whole team, not one person at a time, so everyone hears the same thing. If the drift has gone on long enough to change how your team operates, this older post on giving your culture a fresh start is a good companion, and so is my checklist for spotting where ownership slips through the cracks.
Pick One Unclear Thing This Week
You don’t need to overhaul your leadership style by Friday. Pick one place where you’ve been vague to keep the peace. Maybe it’s a deadline, a behavior you’ve been tolerating, or a “maybe” that’s really a no. Say it plainly and kindly, and then stay consistent with it.
You’ll probably find what I found: people don’t resent clarity. They’re relieved by it. Being someone your team can count on beats being liked, and it tends to bring the liking along with it.
If you want more practical tools like this, Wally Schmader and I wrote the Exceptional Leaders Playbook to give leaders proven lessons they can put to work right away. And if you’d like to watch my TEDx talk or see where else my work has shown up, take a look at my featured talks and articles.
Frequently Asked Questions
What does clear is kind mean?
Clear is kind means that being honest and specific with people is more caring than being vague to keep things comfortable. When leaders hide expectations or soften feedback until it says nothing, people are left guessing and often get blamed later. Clear communication gives people what they need to succeed.
Who said clear is kind, unclear is unkind?
Brené Brown made the phrase widely known in her 2018 book Dare to Lead. She has said she first heard it in a twelve step meeting years earlier and returned to it after her research showed that many leaders avoid clarity because they think it is the kind thing to do.
How do you set boundaries at work without being the bad guy?
Decide the boundaries with your team when you can, put them in plain language, and apply them the same way for everyone. Explain the reason behind them and enforce them calmly and consistently. Teams tend to respect leaders who are predictable, and consistent boundaries usually make a leader more trusted, not less liked.
Is it bad for a leader to want to be liked?
Wanting to be liked is normal. It becomes a problem when it drives decisions, such as bending standards for certain people, avoiding hard answers, or changing course whenever someone is unhappy. Leaders earn lasting respect by being fair, consistent, and clear, and being liked often follows from that.
How can a leader be more consistent?
Agree on a short list of team standards, write them down, and apply them the same way regardless of mood or who is involved. Make decisions with a short pause rather than in the heat of the moment, tell people early about constraints, and when you slip, own it and reset the standard openly with the whole team.